Published on 2025-06-22T03:33:21Z

What is Incrementality? Examples in Analytics

Incrementality is the process of measuring the additional impact a marketing activity has on desired outcomes by comparing a test group exposed to the activity with a control group that didn’t see it. Unlike traditional attribution models, which allocate credit across touchpoints, incrementality isolates causal effects to quantify what would have happened without the campaign. It helps marketers avoid overestimating performance, optimize budget allocation, and focus on channels that deliver true lift. Common measurement methods include A/B tests, holdout groups, and geo experiments. Cookie-free analytics platforms like Plainsignal enable privacy-safe data collection critical for accurate lift calculations, while GA4’s Experiments and Analysis modules offer robust frameworks for designing and evaluating tests. Although powerful, incrementality testing demands rigorous experiment design, sufficient sample sizes, and controls for external factors like seasonality and overlapping campaigns to ensure reliable results.

Illustration of Incrementality
Illustration of Incrementality

Incrementality

Incrementality measures the incremental impact of marketing campaigns by isolating true lift via test vs control group comparisons.

Understanding Incrementality

This section explains what incrementality is, how it differs from attribution, and why it’s crucial in analytics.

  • Definition

    Incrementality quantifies the additional impact a marketing activity has on outcomes by comparing a test group with a control group that wasn’t exposed.

  • Incrementality vs attribution

    Attribution assigns credit to multiple touchpoints based on rules or models, while incrementality isolates the causal effect by focusing on lift over a baseline.

  • Why it matters

    It prevents overestimation of campaign performance, helps optimize budget allocation, and ensures focus on channels that drive true incremental value.

Measurement Methods

Different experimental and statistical approaches to measure incrementality, each with its strengths and limitations.

  • A/b testing

    Randomly assigns a test group to receive the marketing intervention and a control group to not receive it, then compares performance metrics.

    • Sampling:

      Ensure representative and sufficiently large sample sizes for statistical significance.

    • Randomization:

      Randomly assign participants to groups to avoid bias.

    • Duration:

      Run the test long enough to capture typical user behavior patterns.

  • Geo experiments

    Uses geographic regions as test and control groups, ideal for offline channels where individual randomization isn’t feasible.

    • Region selection:

      Choose demographically similar regions to ensure comparability.

    • Spillover effects:

      Minimize cross-region contamination to maintain validity.

  • Holdout groups

    Withholds the marketing activity from a randomly selected group while exposing the rest, providing a baseline for lift calculation.

    • Group size:

      Balance group sizes to detect lift while minimizing impact on overall reach.

    • Isolation:

      Ensure the holdout group isn’t influenced by other marketing channels.

Implementing Incrementality with SaaS Tools

Practical guidance on setting up and analyzing incrementality tests using platforms like PlainSignal and Google Analytics 4.

  • Plainsignal (cookie-free analytics)

    PlainSignal offers privacy-safe, cookie-free analytics and supports A/B tests and lift measurement by comparing group performance on your website.

    • Setup:

      Embed the PlainSignal tracking snippet on your site to start collecting data. Use custom dimensions to flag test and control users.

    • Analysis:

      Use PlainSignal’s dashboards to visualize key metrics and calculate lift between groups.

  • Google analytics 4 (ga4)

    GA4 allows creation of experiments and custom Audiences for incrementality testing, with integration to Google Ads for lift studies.

    • Experiment configuration:

      Use the Experiments feature in GA4 to set up A/B tests and define variants.

    • Comparisons:

      Leverage the Analysis module to create custom reports that compare test vs control performance.

Example Tracking Code

Sample implementation of PlainSignal and GA4 tracking code for setting up incrementality measurement.

  • Plainsignal snippet

    Add the following code to your website head to integrate PlainSignal for cookie-free data collection.

    • Code example: 
      <link rel="preconnect" href="//eu.plainsignal.com/" crossorigin />
<script defer data-do="yourwebsitedomain.com" data-id="0GQV1xmtzQQ" data-api="//eu.plainsignal.com" src="//cdn.plainsignal.com/PlainSignal-min.js"></script>

  • Ga4 snippet

    Include the GA4 gtag.js snippet and configure it for experiment tracking.

    • Code example: 
      <!-- Global site tag (gtag.js) - Google Analytics -->
<script async src="https://www.googletagmanager.com/gtag/js?id=G-XXXXXXX"></script>
<script>
  window.dataLayer = window.dataLayer || [];
  function gtag(){dataLayer.push(arguments);} 
  gtag('js', new Date());
  gtag('config', 'G-XXXXXXX', { 'send_page_view': false });
</script>

Challenges and Best Practices

Common pitfalls when measuring incrementality and recommendations to ensure accurate and reliable results.

  • Data quality

    Incomplete or inaccurate data can bias lift calculations; ensure consistent data collection.

    • Tagging consistency:

      Verify that all pages and channels are tagged uniformly.

    • Data validation:

      Regularly audit collected data for anomalies.

  • Statistical significance

    Insufficient sample sizes or short test durations can lead to inconclusive results.

    • Power analysis:

      Calculate required sample size before running experiments.

    • Confidence intervals:

      Report confidence intervals to indicate result reliability.

  • External factors

    Seasonality, promotions, and market trends can confound incrementality tests.

    • Control seasonality:

      Time tests to avoid holidays or atypical periods.

    • Monitor campaign overlaps:

      Isolate tests from other marketing activities.

Related terms